A Board of Supervisors committee hears the measure Monday afternoon. It would raise the bar for nuisance evictions, let tenants cure damage they have paid for and give them three years to sue over wrongful evictions.
San Francisco’s tenant protections have long turned on a short list of “just causes” a landlord must prove to end a rent-controlled tenancy. One of them, nuisance, is now being used far more often than it was two years ago, and on Monday the Board of Supervisors begins deciding whether to narrow it.
The Land Use and Transportation Committee is scheduled to hear an ordinance from Supervisor Myrna Melgar at 1:30 p.m. that would raise the threshold for evicting residential tenants on nuisance grounds, bar evictions over property damage that a tenant has been allowed to repair or pay for, and set a three-year statute of limitations for wrongful-eviction claims. Supervisors Danny Sauter, Jackie Fielder and Chyanne Chen are listed with Ms. Melgar as sponsors of the measure, file No. 261104 in the board’s legislative record. A full board vote has not been scheduled, The San Francisco Focal reported.
The numbers behind the proposal are stark. The San Francisco Rent Board reported in April that nuisance eviction notices rose 41 percent from March 2025 to February 2026, KQED reported. Mission Local, using Rent Board figures, counted 423 nuisance notices in the 2025-26 fiscal year, up 31 percent from 323 the year before and 47 percent from 288 in 2023-24. Over all, the city recorded 1,495 eviction notices last year, its highest number since the pandemic and a 62 percent increase from 921 in 2024.
“I don’t think it’s because overall tenants are 40% more annoying,” Ms. Melgar told KQED. “I think there’s something going on that is fueling this.”

What would change
San Francisco’s Rent Ordinance now allows a landlord to evict a tenant who commits or permits a nuisance, or who causes substantial damage, and it counts conduct that is severe, recurring or continuing. Under Ms. Melgar’s amendments, as Mission Local described them, an offense would have to be “severe,” or both “recurring” and “continuing,” before it could support an eviction.
The ordinance would also change the core definition. The current code describes a nuisance in part as “creating a substantial interference with the comfort, safety or enjoyment of the landlord or tenants in the building.” The amended language would drop the reference to the landlord and instead count conduct “so disorderly as to destroy the peace and quiet of other occupants,” according to Mission Local.
Three other changes matter in practice:
- Damage that has been fixed. A landlord could not evict over property damage if the landlord has allowed the tenant to repair it or has accepted payment for it.
- Severity examples. Subletting or transferring a unit where the lease prohibits it, seriously damaging the property, letting others damage it, or using the unit for an illegal purpose would remain grounds for eviction.
- More time to sue. Tenants would have three years to bring a claim for wrongful eviction.
The measure would not eliminate nuisance evictions; it would require landlords to meet a clearer and higher standard before pursuing them.
The case that prompted it
Ms. Melgar introduced the measure in October after The San Francisco Standard reported that six households in a single building, five of them headed by seniors, had received nuisance notices for allegedly keeping too many belongings in their apartments. “When I read about Sue Yeng, I cried in the office,” Ms. Melgar said, according to Mission Local, referring to one of the tenants.
“I am introducing this legislation to tighten up the definition of nuisance, so people can’t scam it,” she said at a news conference in the Mission District, where she appeared with Ms. Fielder.
Tenant advocates say the rise reflects incentives, not behavior. Rents for a one-bedroom apartment average $3,915, Mission Local reported, and long-tenured tenants paying controlled rents can be worth far more to a landlord gone. “If you can just empty out a unit of someone who’s been living in there for 30, 40, 50 years and suddenly jack up the rent to whatever you think you can get away with, suddenly landlords are looking for things that they can call a nuisance,” Molly Goldberg, director of the Anti-Displacement Coalition, told the site.
Ms. Melgar has made the same argument, telling KQED that record rents have “added this market-based incentive for landlords to evict long-term tenants, to try and get higher rents for their apartments.”

The landlords’ concern
Landlord groups have warned that overly broad protections could make it harder to deal with genuinely disruptive tenants, according to The Focal’s account of the debate. Their concern is the neighbor who is a danger or a constant disturbance to other renters in the building, the very people the nuisance provision was written to protect. The committee hearing is likely to test whether the new “severe,” “recurring and continuing” language leaves owners a workable path in those cases.
Contested nuisance cases already go to court as unlawful-detainer actions, in which the landlord must prove the cause. The new three-year window for wrongful-eviction suits would lengthen owners’ exposure to claims after a tenancy ends.
A wider push on rents
The ordinance arrives as City Hall treats housing costs as an emergency. In September, Mayor Daniel Lurie declared a rental emergency, citing surging rents and evictions. “Today, most San Franciscans feel our city is finally moving in the right direction, but many are also asking whether they can still afford to live here,” Mr. Lurie said in a statement at the time. His office said it would set aside $30 million to help protect renters from unfair evictions, prevent sudden rent spikes and give tenants legal tools to respond to unlawful landlord behavior.
Ms. Fielder has her own proposal to bar evictions over less than a month’s rent, which Ms. Melgar co-sponsors.
If the committee advances the nuisance ordinance on Monday, it would go to the full board for two readings and then to Mr. Lurie; the reports reviewed by The Inquirer did not include a position from the mayor’s office on the measure.
Celia Marroquín covers San Francisco City Hall, the Board of Supervisors, city departments and the neighborhoods where their decisions land, for the Inquirer’s City Desk. More from Celia Marroquín






