A federal letter issued Friday lets states assess enrollees for six months without cutting anyone off. California’s own filing shows why it may need the time: 71 new eligibility rules, 4.8 million expansion members and a system release that cannot come before July 1, 2027.
On the first day of 2027, a federal law will require millions of Americans covered by Medicaid’s adult expansion to show that they work, study, volunteer or earn enough to be counted as working. In California, that means about 4.8 million Medi-Cal members ages 19 to 64.
On Friday afternoon, 10 days after the midterm elections, the Trump administration told states that they will not have to deny or end anyone’s coverage for failing that test until July 1.
The announcement from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, and the four-page letter to state Medicaid directors behind it, are a significant change in how the requirement will begin. A review by The Inquirer of the letter, of California’s request for more time, and of the early experience in Montana and Nebraska shows that the change rests on a problem that federal officials, state officials and outside analysts each describe in similar terms: the systems that must decide who keeps coverage are not ready to decide it accurately.
What the administration announced, and why
The work requirement comes from Section 71119 of H.R. 1, the budget and tax law President Trump signed in July 2025. It applies to adults who qualify through the Affordable Care Act’s Medicaid expansion and requires 80 hours a month of work, community service, participation in a work program or at least half-time school, a combination of those, or monthly income at a set threshold. Parents of children under 14, people deemed medically frail and several other groups are excluded.
The administration has described the requirement as a way to connect enrollees to work, education and training, building what CMS calls “paths to prosperity,” and it has kept the Jan. 1 start date set by Congress. What changed on Friday is enforcement. Under State Medicaid Director Letter 26-006, states may opt into a “hold harmless” period through June 30, 2027. During that time they must assess whether each applicant and enrollee meets the requirement or is excluded, but they “will not deny applications or disenroll otherwise eligible individuals solely for failure to meet the requirement,” CMS said.
The agency framed the move as a response to the states. “States have made real progress, and they’ve been clear with us about what it takes to get this right for beneficiaries—at scale and for the long term,” said Dan Brillman, the CMS deputy administrator who directs the Center for Medicaid and CHIP Services. “If the state can use data to show that someone is working or qualifies for an exclusion, that person should not have to track down paperwork to prove it.”
He added: “That’s how we build a Medicaid program that works better for people, connects them to work, education, and training opportunities, and supports paths to prosperity.”
CMS also urged every state to maximize automated verification, using data it already holds before asking enrollees for documents; to send clear notices explaining what has been verified and what is still needed; and to test data matching, notices and eligibility decisions end to end before enforcement begins.

What the letter does, and does not, do
The letter’s terms are narrower than some early coverage suggested. A close reading by Jim Hickman, who writes the CalAIM Field Notes newsletter on California’s Medicaid program, lists the key points:
- It is optional. A state requests the period in its mitigation plan and needs CMS approval. States that want it to begin Jan. 1 are asked to notify CMS by Friday, Dec. 11.
- Assessment is the price of admission. CMS will not allow the period unless the state actually assesses each person. That means states must run the new rules from January even if no one is cut off under them.
- It covers only the work rule. Denials and terminations for income, age and other eligibility factors continue as usual.
- It protects states in audits. Determinations made during an approved period will not count as errors in the federal Payment Error Rate Measurement or Medicaid Eligibility Quality Control reviews.
- It ends. For applications filed and renewals begun after the period, states must deny or terminate coverage once federal noncompliance procedures are followed.
The letter also addresses an Oct. 29 federal court ruling in Boston, in Massachusetts v. Oz, that struck an added impairment test from the rule’s medical frailty exclusion. California is a plaintiff in that case. A footnote says states need not build toward the vacated test; CMS has said it will appeal.
What California told Washington
California had already asked for something different. In October, the Department of Health Care Services filed a request for a six-month “good faith effort” exemption, a separate mechanism in the statute that would push back the state’s obligation to implement the requirement at all.
The 15-page filing is unusually blunt about the cause. It says the department built toward a Jan. 1 launch from the statute’s passage in July 2025, and as recently as May 2026 demonstrated to CMS “that California was fully prepared to go live on January 1, 2027.” Then, on June 3, CMS published its interim final rule.
“The IFR materially departs from the statutory language and preliminary CMS guidance that DHCS reasonably relied on,” the department wrote. “The substantial changes required under the IFR make it impossible for California to be fully compliant by the January 1, 2027 implementation date. Proceeding on this timeline would result in premature implementation of a partially compliant system and put approximately 4.8 million Medi-Cal expansion members at risk of eligibility determinations that are inconsistent with the IFR requirements.”
The department counted 71 new business rules that must be designed, built, tested and deployed in the state’s eligibility systems, which run through two large platforms, the California Statewide Automated Welfare System and the California Healthcare Eligibility, Enrollment and Retention System, and through 58 county welfare offices. Its revised roadmap sets implementation “no sooner than July 1, 2027.”
The examples it gives show how much of the work lies in sequence and detail rather than policy:
- Exclusions first. The rule requires states to determine whether someone qualifies for an exclusion before checking whether they meet the work test. “This sequencing was not communicated as a requirement by CMS at any point prior to the IFR,” the filing says.
- A hierarchy within exclusions. States must prioritize statuses unlikely to change, such as parents of young children and disabled veterans, track each status’s duration, and set reverification dates. The department says these “cannot be collapsed into a single indicator.”
- Medical frailty. The rule required states to judge not only whether a person has a qualifying condition but whether it significantly impairs the ability to comply, and CMS’s verification framework arrived for the first time in September, the filing says. That impairment test is the provision the Boston court has since struck.
- Counting hours. For people below the income threshold, states may convert earnings into work hours, convert part-time course credits at three hours of activity per credit per week, and add community service. For volunteer work, caseworkers must capture enough detail to evaluate whether the activity was partisan in nature, plus dates, hours and a contact at the sponsoring organization.
The department says it has not been idle. California’s budget, enacted June 29, set aside $709 million, including $196.8 million in state funds, for county work on the federal Medicaid changes. The state added Equifax and Truv data services to its systems contract as new sources of electronic income and employment verification, secured $17.5 million for a public outreach campaign, and began weekly training for county eligibility workers in August.

The hold-harmless option is not what California asked for
The two mechanisms are not the same. A good-faith exemption, if granted, would delay California’s implementation. The hold-harmless option starts the clock on Jan. 1 but suspends the consequences. Mr. Hickman noted that California’s request “doesn’t say assessments would run during that window,” while “the hold harmless option requires them.”
Friday’s letter invites states with pending exemption requests to update them. According to the Healthcare Financial Management Association, as cited by Mr. Hickman, CMS has not granted an exemption to any state. That leaves California with a decision by Dec. 11 about whether to opt into hold harmless, and how much assessment its systems can run by January.
What the early states show
Two states began early, and their results explain both sides’ concern.
Montana started on July 1, 2026, with a three-month hold-harmless period. Two weeks before it ended, the state health department had no estimate of how many people had been found noncompliant, the Montana Budget and Policy Center reported, according to CalAIM Field Notes. The claims interface for identifying medically frail members was set to go live Oct. 1, the day after the protection expired.
Nebraska started in May. Preliminary data presented to its Medicaid advisory committee showed that more than 9 in 10 people subject to the requirement and due for renewal in July and August qualified, The Associated Press reported. But 533 were denied continuing coverage, most over paperwork. Of those, 43 lost coverage because they did not meet the requirement itself.
“There are likely people who are still eligible for coverage who lost it,” Amy Behnke, chief executive of the Health Care Center Association of Nebraska, told the AP.
Read another way, the same figures show that more than 90 percent of those due for renewal qualified, and that most denials stemmed from verification, the step the administration’s guidance now tells states to automate. CMS’s own impact analysis attributes nearly 43 percent of its projected coverage losses to procedural reasons, according to a summary of the rule by Applied Policy that Mr. Hickman cites.
The reaction
Those who run and study Medicaid welcomed the extra time. “I think these extra six months are going to give states the ability to respond to the change, and there will be fewer people that lose their coverage due to administrative failures,” Kathy Hempstead, a senior policy officer at the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, told the AP. She said it was not clear which states would use it.
Kate McEvoy, executive director of the National Association of Medicaid Directors, said state Medicaid leaders “appreciate the additional flexibility that CMS is providing.”
Democrats, who will control both chambers of Congress in January, have said they want to roll the requirement back. Earlier in the week, Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon and Rep. Frank Pallone Jr. of New Jersey asked CMS Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz to delay implementation, citing the Boston ruling. “The practical reality is that this significant implementation issue may not be definitively resolved for months, creating untenable uncertainty for states that need a final resolution of this issue before going live with work reporting requirements,” their letter said.
What to watch
For Californians on Medi-Cal, the practical question is what arrives in the mail. CMS’s guidance urges notices that tell people what the state has already verified and what is still missing. Under hold harmless, a notice like that could give members months to fix a gap before it costs them coverage. A member who fails to return a renewal packet would still be exposed on other grounds.
The state has until Dec. 11 to choose. DHCS had not announced which route it will take as of Sunday. Whatever it decides, the six months that follow will produce something no one has yet: a count of how many Californians the systems can verify from data alone, how many are excluded and under which exclusion, and how many could not be cleared. That number, more than the start date, will determine what happens on July 1.
Anjali Venkatram covers national news and the federal policies, court rulings and trends that reach California, for National News. More from Anjali Venkatram






