The proposed decision applies AB 1054’s presumption that a utility with a safety certificate acted prudently, and finds that ratepayer advocates did not raise “a serious doubt.” The full commission votes next.
When Gov. Gavin Newsom signed Assembly Bill 1054 in July 2019, with Pacific Gas and Electric in bankruptcy and its own equipment blamed for the deadliest fire in state history, the law’s central bargain was easy to state and hard to test. Utilities that kept a valid wildfire safety certificate would be presumed to have acted reasonably, and customers would cover fire costs unless someone raised serious doubt about that conduct.
On Friday, an administrative law judge at the California Public Utilities Commission applied that bargain for the first time, and PG&E’s customers came out on the paying end.
In a proposed decision in PG&E’s application for cost recovery, the judge found that ratepayers, not shareholders, should cover the outstanding costs from the 2019 Kincade fire in Sonoma County and the 2021 Dixie fire in the northern Sierra, NBC Bay Area reported. If the commission adopts it, the total bill for customers would be about $1.7 billion, on top of the roughly $1.2 billion PG&E has already drawn from the state’s Wildfire Fund for the two fires.
“PG&E’s conduct related to the ignition of the Kincade and Dixie Fires is presumed to have been reasonable (or prudent), and no party to the proceeding has created a serious doubt as to the reasonableness of PG&E’s conduct leading up to the fires,” the decision states.

What the law requires
AB 1054 created the Wildfire Fund, financed by utility customers and shareholders, to pay claims from utility-caused fires and keep California’s investor-owned utilities solvent. When a utility draws on the fund, the commission later reviews whether it acted prudently, and under the statute the burden shifts: a utility with a current safety certificate is presumed prudent unless another party creates “serious doubt.”
The judge concluded that the commission’s ratepayer advocates had not shown that PG&E broke the law, violated commission standards, or behaved differently from how a reasonable utility would have in the same situation, according to NBC Bay Area.
PG&E argued that the outcome is what the Legislature intended. At a recent hearing, the utility’s president, Carla Peterman, said its certification entitled it to the presumption and that advocates had produced no evidence to overcome it. Denying full recovery, she argued, would undermine the law and put the company’s access to financing at risk, which could raise customer costs further. Henry Weissmann, a lawyer for PG&E, said the advocates had offered only opinions about what the utility could have done differently, never showing its practices were substandard.
The two fires
The Dixie fire began on July 13, 2021, in the Feather River Canyon in Butte County, where a tree fell on a PG&E line. It went on to burn nearly a million acres across five counties, the largest single wildfire in California history.
The Public Advocates Office, the commission’s independent ratepayer arm, argued that PG&E managers should have de-energized the line by midday, hours before the fire started, given warning signs in the control room. Instead, the line stayed live until a troubleshooter reached the remote site. PG&E said its operators saw nothing indicating a dangerous condition, handled the event under company policy, and that the troubleshooter was delayed because a bridge was closed for maintenance.

The Kincade fire began in October 2019 near Geyserville and forced the evacuation of nearly 200,000 people in Sonoma County. Advocates argued that PG&E left part of an idle high-voltage transmission line in place, and energized, for more than a decade without a formal risk assessment. The utility said the equipment was kept to make it easier to restore power to a nearby mothballed geothermal plant if needed.
What customers would pay
PG&E’s application sought recovery of about $713 million in Kincade claims and $511 million in Dixie claims, plus about $70 million and $155 million in associated legal costs, and catastrophic event costs of about $83 million in capital and $245 million in operations and maintenance. The Wildfire Fund had already paid about $128 million toward Kincade and about $1.035 billion toward Dixie.
How that would show up on bills, and over what period, is a question for the commission’s final decision and later rate filings. The Small Business Utility Advocates joined the Public Advocates Office in opposing full recovery.
What comes next
A proposed decision is not final. Parties may file comments, and the five commissioners, all appointed by the governor, can adopt it, modify it or issue an alternate. The decision will shape future cases far beyond these two fires: it is the first time the commission has defined what “serious doubt” means in practice, and it could guide later reviews involving other certified utilities, including any cost-recovery case Southern California Edison brings over the Eaton fire.
For the Legislature, which added money to the Wildfire Fund in 2025 after the Los Angeles fires, the case is a reminder of who carries the risk once the fund pays. Under the 2019 law, it is largely the customers.
Graham Ostrowski covers the governor, the Legislature, state agencies and the state budget for the Sacramento Report. More from Graham Ostrowski
Correction: Nov. 16, 2026 — An earlier version of this article misstated the amount the state’s Wildfire Fund had already paid toward the Dixie fire. It was about $1.035 billion, not $1.16 billion.






