The 45-day pause expires at the end of November. A city report finds peak demand rising toward the roughly 1,000 megawatts that can be brought into San Francisco, and lays out options from a power cap to cleaner backup generators.
San Francisco has no pending applications for a new stand-alone data center. On Tuesday, the Board of Supervisors will decide whether to keep it that way for most of next year.
The board is scheduled to vote on first reading of File No. 261175, an urgency ordinance from Supervisor Shamann Walton that would extend the citywide interim moratorium on data centers for 10 months and 15 days. The original 45-day pause, adopted last month as Ordinance 215-26, runs out at the end of November. Because the extension is an urgency measure under Section 65858 of the state Government Code, it needs nine of the board’s 11 votes, The San Francisco Standard reported. Supervisors Jackie Fielder, Chyanne Chen and Connie Chan are co-sponsors.
The vote follows a Nov. 10 Planning Department report prepared at Mayor Daniel Lurie’s request and under the moratorium ordinance. The report does not recommend whether to extend the pause. It describes itself as an initial assessment and lists questions it could not yet answer.
A grid with little room
The report’s most consequential finding concerns electricity. San Francisco no longer generates utility-scale power within its borders; its last two fossil-fuel plants, at Hunters Point and Potrero, were decommissioned, the last in 2011. Nearly all of the city’s power arrives through a few connections: underwater cable across the bay and lines running up the Peninsula.
The total peak transmission capacity into the city is about 1,000 megawatts, the report says, and 400 megawatts of that comes over the Transbay Cable, completed in 2010. Peak use reached about 900 megawatts in 2019. It fell to about 800 megawatts by 2025, according to information from Pacific Gas and Electric, as offices emptied and population dipped, and has been rising since. PG&E and the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission estimate growth of about 2 percent, or up to 20 megawatts, a year from new construction, building electrification and electric vehicles.
Against that margin, the report sets out the scale of the facilities in question. Existing homes in the city use roughly 1 to 1.5 megawatts per 1,000 units. “A data center of 50 MW would use as much power as over 25,000 new homes,” the report says, and a hyperscale facility of 100 megawatts or more “as much power as over 50,000 or more new homes.”
“Concern exists that construction of one or more large data centers in the nearer term could crowd-out available capacity needed for development of new housing and commercial space and for efforts to advance electrification before additional transmission capacity comes online,” the report says.

Where the city’s data centers are
The department identified three stand-alone data center projects in its records and cautioned that the list is not a complete inventory. Two are on the Paul Avenue corridor in the Bayview: 200 Paul Avenue, an existing campus approved for expansion in 2013, and 320-400 Paul Avenue, approved in 2014. The third, 365 Main Street, is in the South of Market. All three sit inside areas the city designates as environmental justice communities, and the Paul Avenue sites fall within the state’s AB 617 air-quality planning area for Bayview Hunters Point and southeast San Francisco. For scale, the report estimates the 200 Paul Avenue facility at 493,000 square feet and 38 megawatts.
“These geographic overlaps do not necessarily indicate that existing facilities are causing significant environmental impacts,” the report says. “However, they illustrate why issues such as backup generator emissions, noise, cumulative environmental burdens, and infrastructure investments have become important considerations.”
The report also notes that the city recently reviewed amendments to the Potrero Power Station development agreement that would have allowed a data center on one block if one were proposed later. No data center was proposed.
What the city could do
The report lists options rather than recommendations. Among them:
- Requiring an assessment from the serving utility of available capacity, grid impacts, needed upgrades and service timelines before a project is entitled.
- Studying a cap on cumulative data center power in the city, with 50 megawatts given as an example and the actual figure to be determined, so that the city keeps enough capacity for its state housing targets.
- Considering whether data center growth, if it does not crowd out other users, could help pay for and speed new transmission into San Francisco.
- Pressing for alternatives to diesel backup generators, such as battery storage, and adding generator noise limits to the city’s Noise Ordinance, including testing only between 7 a.m. and 8 p.m.
- Limiting data centers in residential and neighborhood commercial districts and near major transit stations.
On water, the department estimated the centers’ highest daily use at about 35,000 gallons, “which is within the range of other large development projects,” and flagged the S.F.P.U.C.’s questions about cooling chemicals and wastewater temperature limits. On jobs, it found that large facilities may employ substantially less than one permanent worker per megawatt.

The case for and against
Supporters of the extension say the city needs more time to collect data it does not have. “Transparency about water and energy demands enforceable community benefits and a real opportunity for residents to weigh in before projects are approved, not after,” Mr. Walton said at a committee meeting last month, according to The Standard.
Bradley Angel, executive director of Greenaction for Health and Environmental Justice, a Bayview-based group, told The Inquirer in an email that the organization supports extending the moratorium and favors a ban on proposed large AI data centers. “The use of many back-up diesel generators in and near neighborhoods that are already cumulatively impacted by pollution is not acceptable as it poses direct health risks for vulnerable residents,” Mr. Angel wrote. He said the group wants “full transparency about existing AI Data Centers,” including permitting, emissions, and water and energy use, and “new permit processes including full environmental reviews with meaningful public participation.” Greenaction also sent the board a letter supporting the extension.
The report itself presents the other side of the ledger. Data centers support cloud computing, artificial intelligence, telecommunications and financial systems, it says, and “may contribute to utility and infrastructure improvements.” With no applications pending, critics of an extended pause have argued that a moratorium sends a signal to investors at a moment when the city is courting the artificial intelligence industry. A lobbyist for a private equity firm that develops data centers met with top city officials in August about a large Dogpatch parcel at 1215 Michigan Street, The Standard reported.
Mr. Lurie’s office declined to say whether he supports an extension, The San Francisco Chronicle reported last week. The Inquirer asked Mr. Walton’s office, the S.F.P.U.C. and PG&E for comment; none had responded by publication. The office of Supervisor-elect Theo Ellington, who succeeds Mr. Walton in January and called for a moratorium in southeast San Francisco during his campaign, sent an automated reply.
What happens next
San Francisco is not alone. The Oakland City Council last week extended its own moratorium until October 2027. If San Francisco’s board passes the extension on first reading Tuesday, it would return for a second vote before going to Mr. Lurie. State law allows a further extension of up to a year after this one. The Tuesday vote will be among the last for Mr. Walton and board President Rafael Mandelman, who both leave office in January.
Celia Marroquín covers San Francisco City Hall, the Board of Supervisors, city departments and the neighborhoods where their decisions land, for the Inquirer’s City Desk. More from Celia Marroquín






