A bold tradition of truth telling.

·

Inquirer Investigation: After the ground stop, Duffy wants $50 billion for air traffic control. What last year’s $12.5 billion has bought, what is unspent, and the ICE money Democrats want to move

The Wilbur Wright Federal Building, headquarters of the Federal Aviation Administration, in Washington

Friday’s nationwide halt began on a contractor-run network the FAA set out to replace. The administration now wants a $50 billion package; Democrats say billions already appropriated have not been spent, and a September watchdog report warned the agency was buying speed at the cost of certainty.

By Adaeze Monroe

On Friday afternoon, for nearly five hours, the Federal Aviation Administration told every commercial flight in the country to stay on the ground. The system that carries radio and radar data to air traffic controllers had become unstable. About 3,500 aircraft already in the air landed safely, the agency later said, and operators canceled more than 12,000 flights, not all of them because of the stop itself.

By Sunday, Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy was asking Congress for $50 billion, after having sent lawmakers a $30.1 billion request only the day before the outage. President Trump, in a Truth Social post, urged Congress to “give the money, FAST!” and to do the work “all at once, not in drips and drabs.” He blamed the Biden administration for setting the modernization effort “back years.”

The Inquirer set last year’s $12.5 billion appropriation, the agency’s own spending figures, a September report by the Government Accountability Office and the competing proposals now on the table against one another. The picture is more complicated than a simple shortfall. Billions already appropriated have not been spent. Some of the money is on a legal hold until late 2027. The administration says the existing funds cannot be used for the work it now wants to do. And the outage itself, the FAA says, began on the legacy network, not on the new fiber the money was meant to buy.

What happened on Friday

According to a questions-and-answers document the FAA posted on Sunday, instability began at 17 of the agency’s 22 Air Route Traffic Control Centers around 3:30 p.m. Eastern time on Nov. 13 and spread into several approach-control facilities. The agency issued a nationwide ground stop “out of an abundance of caution.” The system was declared stable and flights resumed at 8:15 p.m.

The cause, the FAA said, was a flood of data on the Federal Telecommunications Infrastructure network, at a rate of about 1,000 connection attempts every four to five seconds, which “created instability with aircraft communications and radar feeds.” The initial investigation pointed to a radar site in Amarillo, Texas, and a radio communications site in El Dorado, Arkansas, where L3Harris Technologies, the network’s current service provider, had been installing a new router. L3Harris blocked those two locations and disabled a broadcasting function on all the new routers, the agency said, and the network stabilized. The FAA said it had “no indication” of a cyberattack.

“It is important to distinguish routine equipment upgrades from the FAA’s broader modernization effort,” the agency wrote. None of the towers already upgraded with last year’s money “went down,” it said, and the disruption “is due to the legacy TDM system causing instabilities.” TDM, or time-division multiplexing, is the analog technology behind the copper lines the agency has been replacing.

L3Harris is also the lead contractor on that replacement, a project funded in part by the $12.5 billion Congress appropriated last year in the reconciliation law, including $4.75 billion for “telecommunications infrastructure modernization and systems upgrades.” Mr. Duffy said on Saturday that the agency had spent about one-third of the modernization budget so far, CNN reported. As of Oct. 15, he and White House budget director Russell Vought told lawmakers, more than 68 percent of the legacy copper wires had been replaced.

The Inquirer reported on Sunday on the history of that contractor-owned network and the FAA’s 2023 plan to replace it. The FAA and L3Harris are still investigating the root cause. It is not yet clear whether the router work itself, a fault in the new equipment, or the interaction with the old network set off the flood of data.

Aerial view of San Francisco International Airport
San Francisco International Airport from the air. Photo: Daniel L. Lu / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

What last year’s money has bought, and what it has not

The $12.5 billion is the first installment of what the FAA calls the Brand New Air Traffic Control System, or BNATCS, launched in May 2025 with a target of finishing Phase 1 by December 2028. The program was a response to a long record of aging equipment. A 2024 G.A.O. assessment found that 51 of the agency’s 138 air traffic control systems were classified as unsustainable and 54 more as potentially unsustainable, with obsolete parts and dwindling vendor support.

On the fiber work, progress is measurable. As of May, the agency had replaced 2,560 of 5,170 aging copper network lines, the G.A.O. reported in September, a figure consistent with the administration’s later claim that more than two-thirds were done by mid-October. In December 2025 the FAA awarded a $1.5 billion contract to Peraton as prime integrator. In May, the Department of Transportation committed more than $750 million to replace eight aging control towers and radar facilities, including the main towers at San Jose Mineta and Sacramento International airports. The first ground-based replacement surveillance radar under the program went in at Putnam, Oklahoma, in June, part of a planned 612-radar rollout.

What the money has not bought is as important as what it has. Phase 2, which would build the automation systems that track aircraft and manage traffic, has no start or end date. The FAA estimates it will need about $10.2 billion for that phase, not counting facilities, the G.A.O. found. Mr. Duffy made the same point on CNN’s “State of the Union” on Sunday: “I’ve got money for radar, I’ve got money for radios. But I have no money for a new network. I don’t have any new money to build new software to separate planes in the airspace.”

In a Sept. 14 report, the G.A.O. found that Phase 1 was projected at $10.6 billion and still faced a $574 million shortfall after Congress’s earlier appropriations and $1 billion the FAA planned to tap from its current-year budget. The agency, the watchdog wrote, “is buying delivery speed at the risk of cost uncertainty and potential disruptions.” It had not produced a comprehensive lifecycle cost estimate or an integrated master schedule, and was managing more than 11,000 unintegrated project schedules. “The net effect could be that air traffic controllers are forced to continue to rely on severely outdated systems that are prone to failure leading to more system outages, ground stops, flight delays, or worse — safety incidents,” the report said.

That warning preceded Friday’s stop by two months.

The unspent billions, and the hold until 2027

House Appropriations Democrats say the problem is not a lack of money. Representatives Rosa DeLauro of Connecticut and James Clyburn of South Carolina said Sunday that $9 billion remains unspent out of $14.4 billion appropriated for air traffic control upgrades since last July, a total that includes the reconciliation funds and $1.9 billion from the fiscal 2026 Transportation-HUD spending law, Roll Call reported. In a fact sheet, they pointed to an Office of Management and Budget apportionment that places more than $5 billion of the reconciliation money on hold until Oct. 1, 2027.

“Recent events are not the result of a lack of funding or support from this Congress,” Mr. Clyburn said. Ms. DeLauro called the $50 billion request a “ransom” and said, “Our air traffic controllers have been failed by Secretary Duffy.”

Mr. Duffy, on the same Sunday programs, did not dispute that a large sum remains unspent. He said the money already provided “is all accounted for and will be committed to specific projects by the end of 2028 or early 2029,” and that he lacked the legal flexibility to move it to the work he now wants to do. The reconciliation law, he argued, appropriated funds only for specific purposes. The administration’s $30.1 billion request, and Senator Eric Schmitt’s Modern Skies Act, would give the FAA authority to transfer previously appropriated modernization money among program elements, subject to reporting requirements.

How much of the unspent total is truly available this year, and how much is reserved for later phases or legally deferred, is a question Congress will have to resolve with the O.M.B. apportionment tables in hand. The Democrats’ $9 billion figure and the administration’s claim that the money is “accounted for” can both be true: funds can be programmed for future work and still sit unspent.

The control tower at San Francisco International Airport
The control tower at San Francisco International Airport, one of the California airports affected by Friday’s nationwide ground stop. Photo: Gregory Varnum / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The jump from $30 billion to $50 billion

The $30.1 billion request that Mr. Duffy and Mr. Vought sent Congress on Nov. 12 is the same package embodied in the Modern Skies Act, S. 5572, which Mr. Schmitt, a Missouri Republican, introduced on Sept. 28, with a House companion, H.R. 10683, from Representative Tracey Mann of Kansas. Neither bill has advanced beyond committee referral.

The $30.1 billion breaks down this way, according to the bill text and Mr. Schmitt’s office:

  • $10.1 billion for air traffic control modernization, including $7.2 billion for a common automation platform and common controller workstation, $2 billion for cloud computing and telecommunications, $600 million for strategic air-traffic flow-management technology, and $300 million to consolidate terminal facilities.
  • $10 billion for terminals, towers and other airport improvements, including $2 billion for towers and facilities, $3 billion for discretionary Airport Improvement Program projects and $5 billion for terminal modernization.
  • $10 billion for a terminal reconstruction pilot at up to three medium-hub airports.

Of the $30.1 billion, then, $10.1 billion is for the air traffic control system itself; the rest is for airport buildings. Speaker Mike Johnson, appearing on Fox News on Saturday, said Congress would take up “the newly revised $50 billion” in the lame-duck session as part of “an aggressive legislative package to finish out the year.” Where the additional $20 billion would go has not been itemized in public. Representatives Rick Larsen of Washington and André Carson of Indiana, the ranking Democrats on the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee and its aviation subcommittee, said Transportation and FAA officials were scheduled to brief committee staff on Monday about the $30 billion request, and that they expected “clear answers” at an early December hearing with FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford.

“If they need more, they should come up and justify it,” Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, a senior appropriator, said on “State of the Union.” “I will support what is necessary to have a safe system and a reliable system.”

The ICE money

Other Democrats have a different idea: move money already appropriated for Immigration and Customs Enforcement. According to O.M.B. apportionment documents cited by Roll Call, ICE has about $76.5 billion left in its operations and support account from the 2025 reconciliation law and a later Homeland Security package, and about $65 billion of that is on hold until Oct. 1, 2027. Senator Brian Schatz of Hawaii, a senior appropriator, wrote on social media that “there is a pot of 60 billion extra dollars on top of the regularly appropriated amount for ICE and we should use at least a portion of that money for the FAA. We can solve this problem and not spend any additional taxpayer dollars.”

Mr. Duffy dismissed the idea. “We can do all things, we don’t have to do one versus the other,” he said on “Fox News Sunday,” according to Roll Call. “I don’t think that is the answer. The answer is let’s do everything that’s going to keep Americans safe, whether it’s with immigration or it’s with air travel.” Expanded immigration enforcement is one of its central priorities, and the ICE funding was enacted for that purpose. Any reallocation would have to be written into a spending bill and would need Republican votes in a lame-duck Congress the party still controls.

What it means for California

San Francisco International, San Jose Mineta, Oakland, Sacramento, Los Angeles International, San Diego and the state’s other commercial airports sit at the receiving end of both the outage and the money. Friday’s stop left Bay Area airports with hundreds of delayed and canceled flights into the weekend. The May announcement of more than $750 million for eight towers included San Jose and Sacramento, two of the California facilities whose aging buildings the department has already committed to replace. Any new terminal or tower money in a $30 billion or $50 billion package would be competed for under existing Airport Improvement Program and discretionary rules, in a state whose airports are among the most congested in the country.

The FAA has not said how much of last year’s $12.5 billion has been, or will be, spent in California.

The December deadline

Federal funding runs out on Dec. 11. Mr. Johnson has said the aviation package would be added to year-end legislation. Democrats take the House in January and will then control the committee staff Mr. Larsen said he would rebuild for oversight. Between those two dates sits a narrow window in which a Republican Congress and a Democratic-majority-in-waiting have to decide whether to write a large new check, unlock money already appropriated, move money from somewhere else, or some combination of the three.

The G.A.O.’s September finding remains the most precise official statement of the underlying problem. The agency is replacing an unsustainable system on an accelerated timetable, without a full cost estimate or a single integrated schedule, and it is doing so on a network that, on Friday, still depended on the old equipment the new money was supposed to retire.

Adaeze Monroe covers Congress, the White House and federal agencies, with a focus on what Washington’s decisions mean for California, for the Washington Bureau. More from Adaeze Monroe

Digital All Access

A year of The San Francisco Inquirer for $129.90

An annual subscription is $129.90 a year. That saves $25.98, about 17%, compared with 12 monthly payments of $12.99.

Subscribe

Or subscribe month to month for $12.99.


Discover more from The San Francisco Inquirer

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Have a tip or spotted an error? Write to editor@sfinquirer.com. The Inquirer corrects its mistakes promptly and says so.