A bold tradition of truth telling.

·

A state team rates Oakland Unified at high risk of insolvency. What the score measures, what the district has cut, and what comes next

The main building of Oakland High School on a sunny day

The Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team scored the district at 47.7 percent on 20 warning signs, above the 40 percent line. Its leaders told the school board Thursday: “If you want to blame past leadership, fix it.”

By Desmond Akers

Oakland Unified School District has spent much of the past decade closing schools, cutting budgets and negotiating with a county overseer. A new report from the state’s school finance watchdog says the district is not out of danger.

In a Fiscal Health Risk Analysis dated Oct. 29 and addressed to Superintendent Denise Saddler, the Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team, known as FCMAT, gave the district a risk score of 47.7 percent. Any score above 40 percent places a district in the high-risk category. Megan Reilly, the agency’s chief executive, and Andrea Ward, an intervention specialist, presented the findings to the board on Thursday, The Oaklandside reported.

“It’s up to you to take this report for what it is,” Ms. Reilly told the board. “It is in no way telling you how to do the job that you have, and it is certainly a hard task. This is what you should be watching out for. We are not telling you how to fix the budget. If you want to blame past leadership, fix it.”

What the score measures

FCMAT, created by the Legislature in 1991 under Assembly Bill 1200, scores districts on 20 factors it has found to be common among those that end up insolvent. The analysis of Oakland was triggered in April, when Alameda County Superintendent Alysse Castro issued a notice of concern. It was based largely on the district’s March second interim budget report, which the board certified as “qualified,” meaning the district might not meet its obligations over the next two years.

The report names the highest-risk areas as budget monitoring and updates; collective bargaining agreements; fund balance and the reserve for economic uncertainty; budget development and adoption; the current-year general fund; deficit spending; and leadership and stability.

Some of the most pointed findings concern how the numbers were built. The district’s multiyear projection included unspecified “Other Adjustments” reductions of $78 million in 2026-27 and $72.6 million in 2027-28 to meet the state’s 2 percent minimum reserve, FCMAT wrote, but “did not identify the specific budgetary actions associated with these adjustments.”

Leadership turnover compounded the problem. The board adopted a stabilization scenario in December 2025; the district’s chief business official left in mid-December, and the district hired the consulting firm Hazard, Young, Attea and Associates to finish the detailed plan. “The leadership transition delayed development of the details supporting Scenario 3,” the report says.

Ms. Reilly told the board that budget updates since March would bring the score down to about 44 percent, which is still high risk.

Pay, enrollment and the structure of the budget

The analysis returns repeatedly to labor costs. About 95 percent of the district’s spending last year went to salaries and benefits, according to its unaudited actuals, compared with a statewide average of about 86 percent, Ms. Ward said. The 2026-27 adopted budget puts the share at about 91 percent. She recommended pre-settlement analyses of future contracts that identify where the money for raises will come from.

“Understandably, things are moving at a rapid pace to approve and implement budget solutions to sustain fiscal solvency,” Ms. Ward said. “Consider presenting alternative scenario projections in support of the decision-making process.”

Enrollment, the main driver of state funding, fell from 37,096 noncharter students in 2014-15 to 33,891 in 2025-26, a decline of about 8.6 percent, though FCMAT said it stabilized last year. The district runs 87 schools, programs and early learning centers.

Exterior of McClymonds High School in West Oakland
McClymonds High School in West Oakland. The district operates 87 schools and programs, according to the state team’s report. Photo: Daniel Olsen / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.5

The district’s response

The district says it has already acted. In a statement, it said it had made nearly $76 million in cuts since January and planned more, and it noted that 11 other districts, including San Francisco Unified and Los Angeles Unified, were also rated high risk this year, according to The Oaklandside and Good Day Oakland.

Board members said the root causes predate them. Vice President Valarie Bachelor, who represents District 6, noted that the district began the year with 99 percent of teaching positions filled. “Years of school closures, consolidations and disruptions have made it so that we have financial instability in our district, and that needs to change,” she said. “We cannot repeat these financial practices that brought OUSD to the brink of insolvency.”

A fight over parcel-tax money

The same meeting showed how hard the remaining choices are. Leaders of the commission that oversees Measures N and H, parcel taxes for college and career programs, asked the board to return $3.5 million in reserve funds the district had used for teacher salaries and other positions without their approval. A county review found no impropriety in what the money paid for, but supporters say it bypassed the per-pupil process voters approved.

District leaders also disclosed that $5.1 million from the Measure G1 contingency fund, a middle-school parcel tax, had been redistributed the same way. Ms. Bachelor defended the moves, saying that using the general fund for costs another fund covers means “we are denying resources for our elementary school students.”

“Taking away $3.5 million heavily deprives us students of the resources that we need to succeed,” said Andrew Bloch, a student member of the board.

Exterior of the library at Fremont High School in East Oakland
The library at Fremont High School in East Oakland, home to one of the career academies paid for in part by the Measure N parcel tax. Photo: Syghost / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

What comes next

A high-risk score does not by itself trigger a state takeover; it is a warning to the board and to the county office, which has authority over the district’s budget. The board’s final meeting of the year is Dec. 9, and a new board, some of whose races have not been decided, will be sworn in in January. Its first major test will be the next interim report, and whether the $78 million in unspecified reductions turns into a list of actual cuts.

Desmond Akers covers the cities and counties of the greater Bay Area, from Oakland and San Jose to the Peninsula, the North Bay and the East Bay suburbs, for Around the Region. More from Desmond Akers

Digital All Access

A year of The San Francisco Inquirer for $129.90

An annual subscription is $129.90 a year. That saves $25.98, about 17%, compared with 12 monthly payments of $12.99.

Subscribe

Or subscribe month to month for $12.99.


Discover more from The San Francisco Inquirer

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Have a tip or spotted an error? Write to editor@sfinquirer.com. The Inquirer corrects its mistakes promptly and says so.