Mayor Daniel Lurie’s charter measure would end a 2003 rule requiring the Board of Supervisors to consent before a mayor fires his own police commissioners, a change his campaign says creates clear accountability and critics say could weaken independent oversight of officer discipline.
Since 2003, a San Francisco mayor who wants to fire one of his own appointees to the Police Commission has needed the Board of Supervisors to agree. Proposition F, one of three charter amendments Mayor Daniel Lurie has placed on the Nov. 3 ballot, would remove that requirement.
The change is a small part of a long measure, but it touches one of the city’s most sensitive bodies. The seven-member commission sets police policy and acts as a quasi-judicial panel in misconduct cases, hearing evidence and deciding whether officers should be disciplined or fired. The mayor nominates four members and the Board of Supervisors appoints three. Under current law, removing any of them requires the board’s approval.
Free article limit reached
Keep reading with Digital All Access
You have read your 3 free articles this month. Subscribe for unlimited access to every story: $12.99 a month, or $129.90 a year.
Already a subscriber? Sign in · Or create a free Free Reader account for 3 more free articles a month.






