A bold tradition of truth telling.

·

San Francisco proposes 60 recovery beds at Alamo Square’s Casa Loma as shelter-equity law turns one

The Painted Ladies Victorian houses on Steiner Street facing Alamo Square

The hotel at 610 Fillmore Street would house people leaving drug treatment for up to two years. A year into the city’s geographic equity ordinance, no new traditional shelter has opened, and several have closed.

By Celia Marroquín

San Francisco wants to turn a hotel a few blocks from the Painted Ladies into housing for people who have just finished drug treatment, a test of whether a year-old law meant to spread homeless services beyond the Tenderloin is starting to work.

The site is Casa Loma, at 610 Fillmore Street near Alamo Square Park. Under the city’s plan, it would offer 60 beds for people leaving treatment, who could stay for roughly 18 to 24 months while they move toward more independent living, KQED reported on Tuesday. The city hopes to open it by July, pending approval by the Board of Supervisors.

The program would be modeled on the Marina Inn, a two-year recovery-housing program run by the Salvation Army on the city’s northern edge. That 68-bed site is designed for people who have completed treatment and includes case management and other on-site services meant to help residents move into permanent housing.

“If we don’t invest in a sustainable place for folks to continue to build on the gains that they’ve made after they’ve graduated from treatment, you end up just repeating the cycle over and over,” Dan Tsai, the city’s public health director, told KQED. “It’s why we think this is a really valuable and important piece.”

The intersection of Grove Street and Fillmore Street in San Francisco
Fillmore Street at Grove Street, near Alamo Square, in the neighborhood around the proposed Casa Loma site. Photo: Yair Haklai / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

A law meant to share the load

Last year the city’s leaders voted to bar San Francisco from adding new city-funded homeless shelters or behavioral health and treatment facilities in neighborhoods that already have more services than residents who need them. The measure, known as the geographic equity ordinance, was aimed largely at the Tenderloin, where many of the city’s shelters and low-income housing options are concentrated, and at other neighborhoods such as the Bayview and the Mission.

Under the ordinance, new shelter beds can be added in the Tenderloin only if need rises or if an existing service is replaced.

“The purpose of the geographic equity ordinance was to ensure that every neighborhood is doing more of its fair share to address homelessness, as it is a neighborhood-by-neighborhood issue,” Supervisor Bilal Mahmood, who represents the Tenderloin, told KQED.

“No new shelter can be automatically added into the neighborhood, but if it goes in, it has to swap with something that already exists there,” Mr. Mahmood said. “We are making sure that we are replacing the things that are less needed with things that the neighborhood needs.”

The Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing describes the ordinance as a framework rather than a cap on progress. “Every neighborhood has a role to play in addressing homelessness, and every person experiencing homelessness deserves access to safe shelter and the services they need,” Emily Cohen, a department spokesperson, told KQED. “The Geographic Equity Ordinance provides an important framework for expanding shelter options across the city while recognizing the significant investments and contributions already made by some neighborhoods.”

Treatment beds up, shelter beds down

In the year since the ordinance passed, the city has added treatment and recovery capacity. A behavioral health facility on Treasure Island with more than 120 units includes 44 beds in a new residential treatment program and 84 new recovery-housing beds. A separate building on the island, scheduled to open in 2028, will take in 172 existing recovery-housing beds now housed in former Navy housing.

Another proposal would add transitional beds for survivors of domestic violence in a Tenderloin building that now offers permanent supportive housing.

The shift tracks a change in emphasis by Mayor Daniel Lurie. Six months into his term, Mr. Lurie moved away from a campaign promise to build 1,500 shelter beds, saying the city should focus more on building the right types of beds, KQED reported. He has made expanding drug treatment a priority.

Panorama of Treasure Island in San Francisco Bay at sunset
Treasure Island, where the city has added a behavioral health facility with residential treatment and recovery-housing beds. Photo: 9yz / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

But the city has not opened any new traditional homeless shelter in the last year, city officials told KQED. Several have closed, including the Andante and the Monarch in the Tenderloin, two hotels converted to shelters during the Covid-19 pandemic. A 280-bed shelter at 711 Post Street is scheduled to close next year. Jerrold Commons in the Bayview and Hope House, an abstinence-based shelter, closed shortly before the ordinance took effect.

Demand still outpaces supply. The city’s online shelter waitlist had 393 people on it as of Monday.

Advocates welcome the step, and worry about the gap

Advocates for homeless San Franciscans have praised step-down housing like Casa Loma and the new beds for domestic violence survivors. Their concern is with what is being lost at the same time.

“We’re seeing over 200 shelter beds close without replacement, and most of that type of shelter is for single adults,” Lukas Illa, policy director of the Coalition on Homelessness, told KQED. “That is severely devastating for the population of folks on the street.”

“In striving for geographic equity, we should not be supplanting cuts elsewhere to our homeless response system,” Mr. Illa said. “We are a very rich city. We need to meet the moment of our behavioral health and affordability crisis that plague our streets. And there is no excuse for shrinking the pot of resources and available shelter units, available housing units.”

The debate has taken on more weight since the Supreme Court’s 2024 ruling in City of Grants Pass v. Johnson, which allows cities to require unhoused people to move off sidewalks whether or not shelter is available. That latitude raises the stakes on where people can go when they are told to move.

What comes next

Casa Loma still needs the Board of Supervisors’ approval before the city can open it next summer. Alamo Square is better known to visitors for its Victorian row houses than for social services, and how the neighborhood receives the plan will be an early measure of whether the ordinance’s promise of shared responsibility holds up outside the Tenderloin.

The Inquirer asked Mr. Mahmood’s office, the Department of Homelessness and Supportive Housing, the mayor’s press office, the Coalition on Homelessness and the Salvation Army about the proposal, including its cost, its operator and the timeline for a board vote. None had responded by publication.

Celia Marroquín covers San Francisco City Hall, the Board of Supervisors, city departments and the neighborhoods where their decisions land, for the Inquirer’s City Desk. More from Celia Marroquín

Digital All Access

A year of The San Francisco Inquirer for $129.90

An annual subscription is $129.90 a year. That saves $25.98, about 17%, compared with 12 monthly payments of $12.99.

Subscribe

Or subscribe month to month for $12.99.


Discover more from The San Francisco Inquirer

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Have a tip or spotted an error? Write to editor@sfinquirer.com. The Inquirer corrects its mistakes promptly and says so.