A bold tradition of truth telling.

·

Santa Clara County deputy public defender says an ICE agent pepper-sprayed him as he recorded an arrest outside the San Jose courthouse

The Santa Clara County Hall of Justice in downtown San Jose

David Oyer has filed a complaint with San Jose police, who say they are investigating. His office says agents have been stationed outside the Hall of Justice and the county jail for a month and that defendants and witnesses are afraid to come to court.

By Desmond Akers

A Santa Clara County deputy public defender says a federal immigration agent pepper-sprayed him in the face as he recorded an arrest outside the county’s Hall of Justice in downtown San Jose, and his office is calling the agents’ conduct “disgusting and reprehensible.”

David Oyer told NBC Bay Area that he was on a sidewalk near the Santa Clara County Main Jail and the Hall of Justice, filming agents from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement as they detained a man, when a confrontation broke out and an agent sprayed him.

“Excruciating,” Mr. Oyer told the station. “It was probably the worst thing I’ve ever felt. I’ve broken bones and had surgeries. It’s like your eyes are on fire for hours.”

He was treated at a hospital, where, he said, his eyes were flushed with fluid from an IV bag. On Monday he went to the San Jose Police Department to file a formal complaint against the agents. “I think I was assaulted,” he told NBC Bay Area. “I’d like to see due process take its course and for the individuals involved to be held accountable.”

The Santa Clara County Main Jail complex in San Jose
The Santa Clara County Main Jail complex, beside the Hall of Justice on West Hedding Street. Photo: Xnatedawgx / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The public defender’s account

In written answers to questions from The Inquirer early Wednesday, Miguel Rodriguez, an assistant public defender who responded on behalf of Chief Assistant Public Defender Sarah McCarthy, gave the office’s account of what happened.

Mr. Oyer and another attorney had left the Hall of Justice after court appearances and were getting into their car, parked in front of the courthouse, when they saw a man running from the building with four or five masked ICE agents chasing him, Mr. Rodriguez wrote. The agents tackled the man, who screamed for help, according to the office. Mr. Oyer joined other people who had gathered to watch and record, and “recorded from a safe distance,” Mr. Rodriguez wrote.

After the man was taken into custody, the office says, several agents began engaging with the onlookers and became aggressive. “With no warning an ICE Agent removed pepper spray and sprayed towards the crowd and directly into Mr. Oyer’s eyes,” Mr. Rodriguez wrote.

Mr. Oyer told NBC Bay Area that he had seen agents push one of the onlookers, “maybe pushing to try to disengage,” before “out of nowhere the ICE agent grabbed his pepper spray.” He said he said nothing to provoke the agents and did not interfere with the arrest.

“We find the actions of the ICE agents to be disgusting and reprehensible,” Mr. Rodriguez wrote. Agents “have staged outside of the Hall of Justice and County Jail for the past month,” he said, and the office believes their behavior “has grown increasingly aggressive and violent.”

The office also says the presence of agents is keeping people away from court. Their tactics “are interfering with the administration of justice as defendants, witnesses and victims are afraid to come to court,” Mr. Rodriguez wrote. He said agents had detained U.S. citizens, including a Latino attorney with the public defender’s office. The Inquirer has not independently confirmed that detention, and the office did not provide details.

The office has told its lawyers how to behave around enforcement actions. “All attorneys have been advised to not interact with ICE agents and maintain a safe distance if recording what they believe might be unlawful conduct of ICE agents,” Mr. Rodriguez wrote. Mr. Oyer, he said, was following those directions when he was sprayed.

San Jose City Hall and its rotunda
San Jose City Hall. Mr. Oyer filed a complaint with the San Jose Police Department, which says it is investigating. Photo: The wub / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

An investigation with obstacles

San Jose police told NBC Bay Area in an email that they were collecting evidence and that the circumstances of the incident were under investigation. The public defender’s office says police told it the same.

Mr. Rodriguez said any investigation “will be complicated by the fact that the ICE agents wear mask, will not identify themselves upon request or provide a badge number and are travelling in vehicles with no license plates.”

Mike Leininger, a retired San Jose police investigator who works as a law enforcement analyst, told NBC Bay Area that Mr. Oyer was likely to run into what he called a federal roadblock. “There’s going to be a problem,” Mr. Leininger said. “The federal government has consistently not cooperated with local law enforcement.” He added: “Their escalation seems to go up rapidly. I don’t see very many de-escalation tactics being employed, and it seems that pepper spray is often their go-to.”

Questions about local jurisdiction over federal agents are not new in California. Federal officers acting within the scope of their duties can claim immunity from state prosecution under the Constitution’s supremacy clause, a defense that has made state charges against federal agents rare, and it is not clear what evidence San Jose police have been able to gather about the agent involved.

The federal side

ICE and the Department of Homeland Security, which oversees it, have not given a public account of the encounter. NBC Bay Area said it had asked both agencies for comment and had not immediately heard back.

The Inquirer emailed ICE’s press office on Tuesday asking for the agency’s account of the arrest, whether an agent used pepper spray and why, and what its policy is on the use of chemical irritants near bystanders who are recording. ICE did not respond by publication. The Inquirer also asked Mr. Oyer, the San Jose mayor’s office and the American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California for comment; none had responded by publication.

The man whose arrest Mr. Oyer was recording has not been publicly identified, and it is not known what immigration or criminal charges, if any, he faces.

Desmond Akers covers the cities and counties of the greater Bay Area, from Oakland and San Jose to the Peninsula, the North Bay and the East Bay suburbs, for Around the Region. More from Desmond Akers

Digital All Access

A year of The San Francisco Inquirer for $129.90

An annual subscription is $129.90 a year. That saves $25.98, about 17%, compared with 12 monthly payments of $12.99.

Subscribe

Or subscribe month to month for $12.99.


Discover more from The San Francisco Inquirer

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Have a tip or spotted an error? Write to editor@sfinquirer.com. The Inquirer corrects its mistakes promptly and says so.