A bold tradition of truth telling.

·

Trump, Xi and Putin will meet in Shenzhen this week, the first three-way summit of their countries’ leaders. Nuclear arms control leads the agenda

High-rise towers of the Shenzhen skyline on a clear day

The White House says the president wants a new arms deal that includes China. A senior official told Reuters not to expect an agreement this time, and Beijing has said joining such talks now would be “neither fair, reasonable nor realistic.”

By Nasrin Haidari

For half a century, nuclear arms control has been a two-party conversation between Washington and Moscow. On Thursday in Shenzhen, President Trump will try to make it three.

The White House has confirmed that Mr. Trump, President Xi Jinping of China and President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia will hold their first trilateral meeting on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit, which China hosts on Wednesday and Thursday, Al Jazeera reported. It will be the first trilateral meeting among the three leaders.

The administration has been plain about its goal. “The president has made it clear that, among other topics, he will discuss the reduction of nuclear weapons in the world. This proliferation, President Trump believes, is very dangerous,” Olivia Wales, a White House spokeswoman, told reporters.

Why arms control leads

The New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty, signed in 2010 to cap the American and Russian strategic arsenals, lapsed in February. Mr. Trump rejected Russia’s proposal to extend the treaty after it expired, demanding instead a “new, improved and modernised” deal that includes Beijing, according to Al Jazeera. Russia holds the most warheads, followed by the United States; China, third, is rapidly expanding its arsenal.

The administration’s priority, according to officials, is to bring both China and Russia into a new agreement. Secretary of State Marco Rubio discussed a possible meeting with China’s foreign minister, Wang Yi, last week, The Inquirer reported.

Expectations are modest. A senior administration official told Reuters that the subject will open the conversation but that “we do not expect to get any kind of agreement.”

A researcher at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory handling a silicon wafer
Research at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, the Alameda County lab that helps design and certify U.S. nuclear weapons. Photo: U.S. Department of Energy / Wikimedia Commons, public domain

Beijing’s position

China has resisted joining. Last month its Foreign Ministry said it would be “neither fair, reasonable nor realistic to ask China to join the so-called trilateral nuclear disarmament negotiations at this stage.” Analysts say Beijing is reluctant to join an agreement it had no part in shaping.

Mr. Putin, for his part, may value the setting as much as the substance. The meeting gives him a “first among equals” position he can display at home, Alexander Bratersky, a Moscow-based journalist and political analyst, told Al Jazeera.

Iran, trade and what is off the table

Officials say the leaders will also discuss the war with Iran, which the United States and Israel began on Feb. 28. Full-scale strikes have stopped, but the Strait of Hormuz remains closed and energy prices volatile. About a third of China’s crude oil supply passed through the strait before the war, giving Beijing a direct interest in reopening it.

Trade is the other constant. Washington and Beijing have reduced tariffs and struck several agreements since the leaders’ meetings in South Korea and Washington, but disputes over advanced chips and rare-earth exports continue.

Ukraine is not expected to come up. A Trump administration official said the president would not raise Russia’s war there, noting that American envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner visited both Ukraine and Russia last week. “China is not really a part of that track, so it doesn’t seem appropriate to have the Ukraine discussion there,” the official told reporters.

Some scholars expect little to come of the meeting. Writing for the Brookings Institution, Jonathan A. Czin, a fellow at its John L. Thornton China Center, invoked a Chinese aphorism, “All thunder, no rain,” to describe the last two Trump-Xi summits, and said it “seems likely to apply to this next summit as well.” Simon Mabon, a professor at Lancaster University in Britain, told Al Jazeera he expected “some pretty impressive photo-ops,” adding that the three leaders “collectively or unilaterally, are not able to bring about an end to the conflict in Iran or Ukraine.”

Three container cranes at the Port of Oakland
Container cranes at the Port of Oakland, a gateway for trade with China. Photo: Jim Heaphy / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The Bay Area stakes

Arms control is not an abstraction in the East Bay. Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, in Alameda County, is one of the two laboratories that design and certify the nation’s nuclear warheads, and any new limits, verification regime or buildup would shape its work and budget for years.

Trade with China runs through the region as well. The Port of Oakland handles a large share of Northern California’s trans-Pacific container traffic, and Bay Area technology companies have a large stake in the U.S.-China dispute over chips and artificial intelligence. Kyle Chan, a Brookings fellow, noted that both governments have agreed in principle to an incident-notification channel for AI risks, a modest step that could be discussed on the sidelines.

Shenzhen, across the border from Hong Kong, is itself a symbol of that relationship: the manufacturing and technology hub where much of the hardware designed in Silicon Valley has long been built. The leaders’ meeting there will show whether the three governments can find any common ground on the weapons that most threaten all of them, or whether, as the administration official suggested, this week is only the first conversation.

Nasrin Haidari covers foreign affairs and geopolitics, including diplomacy, trade disputes and conflicts, and their ties to California and the Pacific. More from Nasrin Haidari

Digital All Access

A year of The San Francisco Inquirer for $129.90

An annual subscription is $129.90 a year. That saves $25.98, about 17%, compared with 12 monthly payments of $12.99.

Subscribe

Or subscribe month to month for $12.99.


Discover more from The San Francisco Inquirer

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Have a tip or spotted an error? Write to editor@sfinquirer.com. The Inquirer corrects its mistakes promptly and says so.