A bold tradition of truth telling.

·

Appeals court throws out class certification in Tesla self-driving case

Tesla's vehicle factory in Fremont, California

A Ninth Circuit panel in San Francisco ruled that California buyers of Tesla’s Full Self-Driving package cannot, for now, sue as a group, because there was no proof every buyer saw the hardware claim at the center of the case.

By Staff Reporter

A federal appeals court on Friday vacated an order that had allowed thousands of California Tesla owners to pursue a class action accusing the company of misleading them about whether their cars had the hardware needed to drive themselves, a significant procedural victory for the automaker in one of the longest-running consumer challenges to its marketing.

In an unpublished memorandum disposition filed Oct. 16, a three-judge panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit held that U.S. District Judge Rita F. Lin of the Northern District of California erred when she inferred that every member of the proposed classes had been exposed to the statement at issue. The panel, made up of Judges Ronald M. Gould, Jay S. Bybee and Daniel P. Bress, vacated all three classes Judge Lin had certified and sent the case back to her courtroom in San Francisco.

The decision does not resolve whether Tesla’s advertising was false. The underlying lawsuit, LoSavio v. Tesla, remains pending.

The ‘Hardware Statement’

The plaintiff, Thomas J. LoSavio, sued in 2022 on behalf of himself and other California buyers, alleging that Tesla violated the state’s consumer protection laws by misrepresenting its cars’ capabilities in connection with the Full Self-Driving packages it sold, often for thousands of dollars on top of a vehicle’s price.

At the heart of the case is what the court called the “Hardware Statement”: Tesla’s claim, published on the Autopilot page of its website, that vehicles sold from October 2016 onward contained the hardware needed for full self-driving capability. In August 2025, Judge Lin certified two damages classes and a third class seeking an injunction, concluding that it was “highly likely” that customers would “visit the website when considering the purchase of an expensive package such as . . . FSD.” Reuters reported at the time that the ruling allowed drivers to proceed as a group.

Why the panel disagreed

To pursue claims as a class under the federal rules, plaintiffs must show that common questions predominate over individual ones. In California false-advertising cases, that often means showing that every class member was exposed to the challenged claim. Courts have presumed such exposure in two kinds of situations, the panel wrote: when a misrepresentation was part of an “extensive and long-term” advertising campaign, and when it appeared on a product’s label or in material given to every customer.

Judge Lin had likened Tesla’s website to a product label, citing what the panel described as the company’s “unique marketing strategy” and the site’s central role in promoting Full Self-Driving. The panel rejected that analogy. A label is in front of every purchaser, the judges wrote, but as the district court itself had recognized, “there [was] no specific requirement forcing [FSD purchasers] through the Autopilot page to complete their purchase.”

Inferring exposure therefore required two assumptions, the panel said: that buyers reached the Autopilot page, and that once there they saw the hardware claim. Even if the claim’s prominence supported the second, “the first assumption prevents an inference of classwide exposure.” Website-traffic data, the judges added, was “consistent with” exposure but did not show that all class members must have seen the statement.

The same problem undermined the court’s handling of Tesla’s statute of limitations defenses, which turn on whether customers saw the company’s explanations, posted on the same webpage, attributing delays in Full Self-Driving to regulatory hurdles. And because the injunctive-relief class was a subset of the damages classes, the panel concluded that it “rises and falls” with them. Having found the exposure question dispositive, the court did not address the plaintiff’s damages model.

Reactions

The plaintiffs’ lawyers said in a statement reported by Reuters that “the panel did not fully appreciate the unique circumstances here, and the importance of the hardware statement to Tesla’s marketing campaign.” Tesla, which has denied the allegations, did not immediately respond to a request for comment from Reuters.

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce had filed a brief supporting Tesla, arguing that the certification order “threatens to substantially increase the costs to businesses and consumers of overbroad and meritless class proceedings,” Reuters reported.

What it means for California

Because the disposition is unpublished, it is not binding precedent under the Ninth Circuit’s rules. But it offers a clear signal to the many consumer-protection suits filed in California’s federal courts against companies whose marketing lives primarily online: a claim prominently displayed on a website will not necessarily be treated like one printed on a box.

For Tesla buyers, the practical effect is that, unless the plaintiffs can rebuild a class on different evidence, individual owners would have to pursue their claims separately, a far costlier proposition for claims that may be worth several thousand dollars each.

The ruling also lands against a backdrop of state scrutiny. In December 2025, the California Department of Motor Vehicles found that Tesla’s use of the terms “Autopilot” and “Full Self-Driving” in its marketing was misleading and violated state law. The agency said in February that Tesla had stopped using “Autopilot” in its California marketing and had already switched to “Full Self-Driving (Supervised),” allowing it to avoid a 30-day license suspension. Tesla has since sued the DMV to overturn the false-advertising finding, CNBC reported.

Although Tesla moved its headquarters to Texas in 2021, its Fremont assembly plant remains one of the largest manufacturing employers in the Bay Area, and its marketing claims about autonomy remain under examination in California’s courts and regulatory agencies.

The case now returns to Judge Lin for further proceedings.

Digital All Access

A year of The San Francisco Inquirer for $129.90

An annual subscription is $129.90 a year. That saves $25.98, about 17%, compared with 12 monthly payments of $12.99.

Subscribe

Or subscribe month to month for $12.99.


Discover more from The San Francisco Inquirer

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Have a tip or spotted an error? Write to editor@sfinquirer.com. The Inquirer corrects its mistakes promptly and says so.