Site icon The San Francisco Inquirer

Inquirer Investigation: No war, no peace in the Gulf. What the U.S. blockade, the fight over the Strait of Hormuz and stalled mediation are costing, and what it means for California fuel prices

The Strait of Hormuz photographed from the space shuttle

The Strait of Hormuz, between Iran and the Musandam Peninsula of Oman, photographed from the space shuttle. Photo: NASA / Wikimedia Commons, public domain

Advertisements

Nine months after the war with Iran began, Washington says its goal is unchanged and its leverage is growing, while Tehran says it will not reopen the strait until the blockade ends. Federal energy data show how much of the shock has reached California’s pumps, and how much may yet unwind.

By Nasrin Haidari

On Tuesday, the United States struck an Iranian missile site on Qeshm Island, in the Strait of Hormuz, hours after Iran launched drones at an American radar in Bahrain. Qatar announced another round of talks with Iranian officials and warned of a “grave danger” to diplomacy. A tanker north of Oman’s Khasab was hit for a second time, and its crew was unaccounted for.

It was, in other words, a fairly typical day in a conflict that has settled into what analysts increasingly describe as neither war nor peace: large-scale bombing has largely stopped, no settlement is in sight, and the world’s most important oil chokepoint remains contested.

The Inquirer reviewed federal energy forecasts, California Energy Commission data, statements from the White House and U.S. Central Command, and reporting from the region to examine where the standoff stands, what each side says it wants, and what it has meant for Californians, who pay more for gasoline than drivers in almost any other state.

Aircraft from Carrier Air Wing 9, embarked on the San Diego-based carrier Abraham Lincoln, over the Arabian Sea on Feb. 6, 2026. Photo: Petty Officer 1st Class Jesse Monford / U.S. Navy, public domain

What the administration says it wants

The White House has been consistent about its central aim. “What President Trump’s number one goal has been and will always be is to ensure that Iran can never obtain a nuclear weapon. Period,” Karoline Leavitt, the White House press secretary, said in a Fox News interview on Aug. 27, according to Reuters. “And so we’ve had Operation Epic Fury to destroy their military. Now we have Operation Economic Outcast to destroy their economy.”

The administration describes the naval blockade of Iranian ports as a response to Iranian violations, not an opening move. The United States and Israel began striking Iran on Feb. 28. Talks mediated by Pakistan produced a memorandum of understanding in June that paused the fighting and briefly lifted the blockade. In July, Ms. Leavitt said the United States had resumed strikes “because Iran violated the memorandum of understanding that we struck with them,” including a commitment not to fire on commercial vessels in the strait, Anadolu Agency reported.

“There is a blockade of ships, directed by the president, for ships entering and departing Iranian ports only,” she said then. “This blockade was reimposed due to Iran’s inability to honor their agreement with the United States. The strait (of Hormuz) is open for ships that are not traveling to and from Iranian ports specifically, and the U.S. Navy is there to ensure that can take place.”

President Trump has signaled he is in no hurry. “We don’t need a deal with Iran,” he wrote on Truth Social late last week, Al Jazeera reported. “Those days have long since passed. We’ve got their money, Hundreds of Billions of Dollars, and we’ve got their Strait!” Earlier, he had said the war was “militarily … effectively over,” while adding that he “would not hesitate” to resume strikes if diplomacy failed.

Vice President JD Vance told Fox News on Monday that the administration would not let the war become a two-year commitment, while reiterating that Iran’s nuclear program remains a threat to the United States, CBS News reported.

The military describes its recent strikes as defensive. Tuesday’s attack on Qeshm Island was launched “in self-defense,” a U.S. military official told CBS News. “The strike was in response to IRGC aggression targeting U.S. personnel and assets,” the official said. “U.S. Central Command remains highly vigilant and fully postured to protect Americans across the region.” It was Iran’s third attempted strike on a U.S. military installation in five days, and all were intercepted, U.S. officials said. The U.S. military also says the shipping lanes in the southern strait are free of mines and safe to use; Iran’s daily claims of ships striking mines have not been confirmed.

Asked by The Inquirer for an update on the blockade and conditions in the strait, CENTCOM’s media operations team replied: “We refer you to our recent press releases and statements on X. We have no additional operational updates at this time.”

What Tehran demands

Iran has set seven conditions for a formal cease-fire, the reopening of the strait and a return to talks, including lifting the blockade, sanctions relief, the release of frozen funds and an end to hostilities on all fronts, Al Jazeera reported. Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf, the parliament speaker and Iran’s chief negotiator, told the network that “the ball is now in the American court,” and has said the strait will “never return” to its prewar, toll-free status.

The pressure on Iran is severe. Its statistics agency reported that the economy shrank 10.1 percent year on year between March and June, and the central bank put annual inflation at 83.8 percent in September, according to Al Jazeera. The federal Energy Information Administration expects Iran’s oil exports to remain constrained through the end of 2027.

Traffic through the strait has collapsed at times. According to the trade intelligence firm Kpler, only five commodity vessels crossed on Nov. 7 and none the next day, Al Jazeera reported.

Chevron’s Richmond refinery, one of the Bay Area refineries that buy crude on world markets. Photo: Bastique / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The mediators

Qatar and Oman are trying to keep a channel open. “It is in no one’s interest to remain in this situation and enter a stalemate,” Majed Al Ansari, the Qatari foreign ministry spokesman, said on Tuesday, according to Euronews. He said the risks of escalation extended “not only to freedom of navigation and the global economy, but also to the chances of reaching an agreement.” The same day, Iran’s foreign minister, Abbas Araghchi, met Oman’s foreign minister, Badr Albusaidi, to discuss preventing further escalation and protecting shipping.

Analysts say neither side has a clean exit. “The war has changed form, from an air campaign to a siege, and sieges end when the besieged side either breaks or breaks out,” Muhanad Seloom of the Doha Institute for Graduate Studies told Al Jazeera. Tallha Abdulrazaq of the University of Exeter said he expected the conflict to “drag on as neither side is willing to back down on their negotiating positions.”

Politics at home add pressure. A Chicago Council on Global Affairs survey in October found that nearly 70 percent of Americans believed the war was not worth fighting, Al Jazeera reported, and Mr. Vance has blamed the war and its economic fallout for Republican losses in the Nov. 3 midterms.

What it has cost California drivers

The war hit California through the price of crude. Before Feb. 28, about 17 percent of the state’s crude oil, or 29 percent of its imported crude, came through the Strait of Hormuz, according to the California Energy Commission. Because California refiners buy on global markets, the commission says, every $10-a-barrel increase in crude translates to roughly 24 cents a gallon at the pump.

The swings have been large. The Brent benchmark averaged $124 a barrel in October, the highest since July 2022, before falling below $100 on Nov. 4 as Middle East exports rose through pipelines and ship-to-ship transfers along Oman’s coast, according to the EIA’s November Short-Term Energy Outlook. Middle East production shut-ins averaged 2.5 million barrels a day in October, down from 10.9 million at the peak in May.

Pump prices are now falling but remain high. In Los Angeles County, regular gasoline averaged $5.601 a gallon on Tuesday, its lowest since July 22 but 90.7 cents higher than when the war began, according to AAA and Oil Price Information Service figures reported by MyNewsLA. The national average was $3.781. On Nov. 5, the Auto Club put California’s statewide average at $5.63, 94 cents above a year earlier.

California-specific programs account for part of the gap with other states. The energy commission puts the Low Carbon Fuel Standard at about 18 cents a gallon and the state’s cap-and-invest program at about 23 cents.

A price board in Chula Vista in late September 2026. Photo: Bnuuy / Wikimedia Commons, CC0

What comes next

The EIA expects relief if the standoff does not worsen. It forecasts Brent at $104 a barrel in November and $99 in December, then below $90 in the second quarter of 2027 and an average of $77 by the fourth quarter as inventories rebuild. It expects most Middle East production outside Iran to return to prewar levels by mid-2027.

But the agency warns that flows through Hormuz and alternative routes “will remain susceptible to disruption.” Mr. Seloom told Al Jazeera that American deaths, “a Hormuz shock that lifts fuel prices again,” or intelligence that Tehran is moving its stock of highly enriched uranium could each end the current equilibrium.

For California, the arithmetic is simple: as long as the strait is contested, every flare-up in the Gulf can show up on price boards from Chula Vista to Concord.

The Inquirer also asked the Energy Information Administration, the California Energy Commission, the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace and the Brookings Institution for comment; none had responded by publication.

Nasrin Haidari covers foreign affairs and geopolitics, including diplomacy, trade disputes and conflicts, and their ties to California and the Pacific. More from Nasrin Haidari

Exit mobile version