Proposition B, unofficially ahead 52.6 percent to 47.3 percent, lets the city form a municipal finance corporation. It does not fund a bank, and Berkeley voters rejected a parcel tax that would have paid for an East Bay one.
San Francisco has become the first American city to vote itself a path to a public bank. It is still years, and a large sum of money, away from having one.
In unofficial returns updated Nov. 10, Proposition B stood at 169,415 yes votes, or 52.6 percent, to 152,252 no, or 47.3 percent, according to KQED’s Associated Press tally. The measure had trailed by about 630 votes on election night and later flipped; the Department of Elections has not yet certified the results. The measure amends the city charter to authorize a Municipal Finance Corporation, a nonprofit, non-depository institution that would later be able to seek a bank charter, and a governance structure meant to keep lending decisions at arm’s length from elected officials.
It does not itself create or fund a bank. That is the work ahead, and it is substantial.
What would have to happen
The corporation would first make loans in partnership with existing local lenders, according to the Reinvestment Working Group business plan that the Board of Supervisors accepted unanimously in 2023. After at least three years, if it can show a successful lending record and become financially self-sustaining, it would have the authority to apply for a banking charter from the California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation and for federal deposit insurance from the F.D.I.C. Only then could it take deposits, primarily from the city itself, not from the general public, Next City reported.
The working group’s plan projects $40 million in seed capital from the city, paid over three years, and at least $50 million more in grants or low-interest loans, much of it also likely from the city. The city controller’s official statement on the measure, cited in the ballot arguments, put the potential cost at $310 million to $460 million over eight years.
Who would run it is already written into the charter amendment. A nine-member oversight commission would appoint the corporation’s board: four members named by the Board of Supervisors, two by the mayor, and one each by the treasurer-tax collector, the controller and the city attorney. Neither the mayor nor the board would appoint a majority.
The case for it
Supporters say a public bank would put the city’s deposits to work on loans for affordable housing, climate infrastructure and small businesses, rather than leaving them in commercial banks. A recent report by the Climate and Community Institute, a progressive think tank cited by KQED, found that the city’s 2023 plan could support as many as 6,000 units of affordable housing and 1,200 small-business loans over 10 years, and return about $2.3 million to depositors and bondholders.
“We’re elated,” Misha Steier, a spokesperson for the San Francisco Public Bank Coalition, told KQED. “A lot of other cities in the U.S. will be looking at San Francisco,” said Prasad Krishnamurthy, who teaches financial regulation at the University of California, Berkeley, School of Law.
“Prop B is an important first step in establishing our public bank,” Supervisor Chyanne Chen, who helped put the measure on the ballot, said in a statement. “I’m especially excited because with Democrats in control of the House and Senate, there may be new avenues available to fund the bank.” Supervisor Jackie Fielder, an early proponent, said the city needs “public institutions that aspire to reimagine how we can invest in our communities and in solutions that address climate change.”
Advocates often point to the Bank of North Dakota, founded in 1919, which reported $231 million in profits in 2025, KQED reported. Unlike that institution, a San Francisco bank would start as a city, not a state, entity, and would work mainly through local private lenders rather than making most loans itself.
The case against it
The city already has tools to finance housing and small business, opponents say, and is facing budget shortfalls. “The election results so far reflect a broader skepticism among San Franciscans about the proper role of government and whether City Hall should be in the business of running a bank,” Supervisor Alan Wong, one of two supervisors who opposed the measure, said in a statement on election night, when it was still trailing. “We can support greater economic opportunity and affordability without embracing costly, unproven solutions.”
Mr. Krishnamurthy, who supports the municipal finance corporation, told KQED he is not convinced the city needs a full public bank and called a later depository institution “very risky.” “The North Dakota structure is a safe structure, but it’s dependent on it being a state economy, not a city,” he said.
Mayor Daniel Lurie opposed the measure but did not campaign against it, Mission Local reported, as cited by The Bay Area Brief.
Across the bay, a different result
Berkeley’s Measure Z, a parcel tax meant to capitalize an East Bay public bank, failed with 55 percent voting no, KQED reported. Supporters said the opposition’s argument that Berkeley property owners would carry an outsized share of a regional bank proved hard to overcome. “It’s not over,” Debbie Notkin, a campaign committee member for Keep Berkeley Money Local and chair of Friends of Public Bank East Bay, told KQED. “We’re thinking about philanthropy. We are not ruling out future ballot measures.”
San Francisco’s measure never asked voters for a tax. That is why it could pass, and why the hardest question is still open. The most “surefire” way to capitalize the bank would be a local revenue source, Misha Steier of the Public Bank Coalition told KQED. Philanthropy, state grants and federal funds are also under discussion.
The Inquirer asked Supervisor Chen’s office for comment; it had not responded by publication. The results remain unofficial until the Department of Elections certifies them.
Wendell Yamashiro covers business, technology, labor, trade and the Bay Area economy for Trade and Commerce. More from Wendell Yamashiro

