President Trump invoked a seldom-used Clean Water Act provision to keep federal air tankers flying through the 2027 fire season while a Montana lawsuit over retardant in streams continues. Cal Fire’s own operations are not clearly covered.
For four years, the red streaks that air tankers lay along California ridgelines have been at the center of a federal lawsuit over whether fire retardant that lands in streams requires a Clean Water Act permit. On Nov. 10, President Trump took that question off the table for the next 12 months.
In a presidential determination published in the Federal Register on Friday, the president exempted “firefighting activities, including the aerial use, deployment, and discharge of fire retardants,” by the Forest Service, the Interior Department, other federal agencies and their contractors from “Federal, State, interstate, and local requirements” for the control and abatement of water pollution. The exemption runs from Nov. 10, 2026, to Nov. 10, 2027.
The administration’s case is that wildfire suppression cannot wait on a permit. The president invoked Section 313(a) of the Clean Water Act, which allows a president to exempt a federal agency’s activities from water-pollution requirements for one year at a time if he determines it is “in the paramount interest of the United States.” A White House fact sheet tied the action to what it called an adverse district court decision, and the White House said permitting delays had created uncertainty over whether retardant would remain available in the 2027 season, AerialFire magazine reported.
The determination also states that it is not an admission that a permit was ever required. Nothing in it is intended to “imply that in the absence of such a Presidential exemption, the Clean Water Act or any other provision of law would require the United States Forest Service or other agencies to obtain permits,” the text says.
The lawsuit behind it
The memo names the case directly: Forest Service Employees for Environmental Ethics v. U.S. Forest Service, filed in federal court in Montana in 2022. The group, an Oregon-based organization of current and former agency employees, argued that retardant dropped into streams and rivers is a pollutant discharge that requires a permit under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System. Its complaint cited 459 instances of retardant entering waterways from 2012 to 2019; the Forest Service’s own reports counted 213.
In 2023, Judge Dana L. Christensen of the U.S. District Court for the District of Montana found that the agency’s unpermitted discharges violated the Clean Water Act, but he declined to stop the use of retardant, citing the risk to firefighters and communities. He later ordered the Forest Service to keep pursuing permit coverage and to file progress reports, according to AerialFire. A draft general permit that the Environmental Protection Agency had prepared was later withdrawn, leaving the agency without coverage heading into the next season.
What it covers, and what it does not
The exemption is broad in one direction and narrow in others.
- It covers federal operations and their contractors. That includes the large and very large air tankers that fly under federal contracts across California’s national forests.
- It does not clearly cover state aircraft. The determination applies to federal agencies and contractors, leaving questions about mixed-jurisdiction fires, state-owned aircraft working under federal orders and missions flown outside a federal contract, AerialFire noted. Cal Fire, which operates its own fleet, is a state agency.
- It keeps two sections in force. The memo excludes 33 U.S.C. 1316 and 1317, the Clean Water Act’s performance standards and its provisions on toxic pollutants.
- It does not lift other rules. The memo says it does not limit “any other requirement of law” governing federal firefighting. The Forest Service’s mapped aquatic avoidance areas, which bar drops near waterways except where human life or safety is at risk, rest on separate environmental reviews and Endangered Species Act consultations and remain in effect.
The exemption expires nine days after a separate deadline in a related Endangered Species Act case, in which existing biological opinions have been allowed to stand until replacements are completed or until Nov. 1, 2027.
Why it matters in California
Retardant is a pillar of initial attack in the state, where wind-driven fires in steep, populated terrain can move faster than ground crews. Federal agencies manage nearly half of California’s land, including 18 national forests, and federal contract tankers routinely work alongside Cal Fire’s aircraft on the same fires.
The chemistry has drawn scrutiny. A 2024 study by researchers at the University of Southern California, published in Environmental Science & Technology Letters, reported that several commercial retardants contained metals including chromium and cadmium, and estimated how much could be released in heavy fire years. Perimeter, the company that makes Phos-Chek, the most widely used retardant, disputed the study’s conclusions.
What comes next
Section 313 allows the president to renew the exemption a year at a time, and the determination does not resolve the underlying litigation or create a permanent permit framework. The next step, AerialFire reported, is guidance from the Forest Service, Interior and the E.P.A. on how the exemption affects avoidance areas, accidental-drop reporting and contract language. For air tanker crews based at California airfields from Redding to Ramona, the practical effect for now is continuity: the maps and procedures they flew under this year remain in place for next year’s season.
Anjali Venkatram covers national news and the federal policies, court rulings and trends that reach California, for National News. More from Anjali Venkatram

