Site icon The San Francisco Inquirer

An Interior plan would make toppling old oil platforms in place the default. What it could mean for the 23 rigs off California, and for the Senate committee that oversees offshore leasing

Platform Holly silhouetted offshore at dusk off Goleta

Platform Holly off Goleta, in state waters. The State Lands Commission is weighing whether to remove it or cut it below the surface. Photo: Glenn Beltz / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

Advertisements

A September executive order on saltwater fishing gives the new Marine Minerals Administration until Monday to set up a federal “reef-in-place” program. Scientists are divided, coastal groups are opposed and industry calls it habitat worth keeping.

By Rosalind Achterberg

The 23 oil and gas platforms that stand in federal waters off California were built to be removed. Their leases require it, and every platform decommissioned off the state so far has been hauled away. A Trump administration plan could change that.

Buried in a September executive order on recreational fishing, President Trump directed the Interior Department, through its newly formed Marine Minerals Administration, to establish a federal “reef-in-place” program for decommissioned offshore platforms, The Los Angeles Times reported on Sunday. The order, Executive Order 14430, “Restoring American Saltwater Angling and Recreation,” signed Sept. 17, set Monday, Nov. 16, as the deadline for that program to be established.

Interior has signaled it intends to go further. A rulemaking scheduled for 2027 would make “toppling in place,” knocking most or all of a platform onto its side to rest on the seabed, the default decommissioning method if approved. It has been done in the Gulf of Mexico but never in the Pacific.

Platform Gail stands in 739 feet of water in the Santa Barbara Channel, one of the federal-water platforms off California. Photo: Ken Lund / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

The administration’s case

The order is framed around fishing and habitat. As the administration and its allies describe it, the steel jackets of offshore platforms, colonized over decades by mussels, anemones and rockfish, function as reefs, and that removing them destroys habitat that anglers and marine life depend on. Federal law has long allowed this in some form: the National Fishing Enhancement Act of 1984 set up the framework under which hundreds of Gulf platforms have been converted to artificial reefs.

The industry agrees. “Offshore energy infrastructure becomes valuable marine habitat, supporting an abundance of fish and other marine life,” Erik Milito, president of the National Ocean Industries Association, said in a statement on related legislation. “Rigs-to-Reefs provides a proven way to preserve that habitat and extend the benefits of offshore infrastructure long after energy production ends.”

The order specifies that offshore wind platforms would not benefit from the change.

What scientists say

Some researchers see real ecological value. Milton Love, a research biologist at the University of California, Santa Barbara, who has studied the platforms’ marine life for decades, told The Times that removal kills the invertebrates on a structure, and that crews sometimes use underwater explosives that kill nearby fish. “They happen to be living next to a piece of steel, and you’re going to kill them for that? I just don’t think that’s right,” he said.

But he cautioned that the Gulf’s experience does not translate neatly. California’s federal-water platforms stand in roughly 95 to 1,200 feet of water, and differences in species, temperature and depth mean the Gulf findings do not really apply to the Pacific, he told The Times. “Putting the platforms in was a great experiment in terms of biology,” Dr. Love said, “and tipping them over would be a great experiment again.”

The critics

Opponents see a financial benefit to operators. Full removal of the largest platforms can exceed $200 million each, according to federal estimates cited by The Times. “Decommissioning via topple in place would be a huge windfall for oil companies in comparison to full removal, allowing them to avoid hundreds of millions of dollars in expenses as well as complex engineering and contracting problems,” said Robert Collier, an oil industry consultant who first flagged the plan on his Substack, Offshore California.

Richard Charter, who directs the Local Government Outer Continental Shelf Coordination Program, a coalition of coastal counties opposed to offshore drilling, said the plan could also encourage new leasing, since companies may be more willing to invest in remote sites if they never have to remove their rigs. “What they’re asking for now isn’t even partial decommissioning — it appears to be ocean dumping,” he said. He predicted legal challenges from coastal groups, counties and possibly the state.

The timing adds to their concern. The White House is seeking to reopen Pacific waters to oil leasing for the first time in more than four decades.

A brown pelican passes an offshore platform near Coal Oil Point in Santa Barbara County. Photo: Channel City Camera Club / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

California’s own rules

California created a rigs-to-reefs program in 2010, under a law signed by Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger. It allows platforms to be reefed case by case, generally by removing their upper portions, with operators sharing cost savings with the state and transferring some long-term liability. It does not allow toppling. No platform has yet been reefed under it.

Platform Holly, in state waters off Goleta, could be the first test. The State Lands Commission is weighing whether to sever it or remove it entirely and is expected to release a draft environmental impact report early next year. Linda Krop, chief counsel of the Environmental Defense Center in Santa Barbara, told The Times she expects the state to favor full removal to avoid long-term liability. “We’re very concerned about leaving this legacy pollution” in the ocean, she said. “If it was onshore, you know no one would allow it.”

Where the Senate comes in

The federal platforms sit on the outer continental shelf, whose leasing and management fall under the jurisdiction of the Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, chaired by Senator Mike Lee of Utah. Any statutory change to decommissioning liability, or any effort to block the administration’s 2027 rule, would run through that committee and its House counterpart.

Congress is already moving in the administration’s direction. A bipartisan House bill, H.R. 5745, would make it easier to convert eligible platforms into reefs by toppling, severing or abandonment, and would allow liability to be transferred to states that accept them into artificial-reef programs in exchange for compensation.

California’s senators have not taken a public position on the reef-in-place program in the reports reviewed by The Inquirer. The broader fight over the state’s authority to object to federal offshore projects under the Coastal Zone Management Act, which the administration is seeking to narrow, may determine how much say Sacramento has when the first California platform comes up for a toppling decision.

Rosalind Achterberg covers the Senate Environment and Public Works and Energy and Natural Resources committees, from permitting and water law to nominations and the federal lands that cover nearly half of California, for the Inquirer’s Energy & Environment desk. More from Rosalind Achterberg

Exit mobile version